I ain’t buying that again.

[Cheekee]

A&E American Pie. smells like burnt something or another.

 

[gile]

A&E Turkish coffee burns like hell. I gave it to three friends and they also suffered.

 

[TheChrisC]

A&E Turkish coffee burns like hell. I gave it to three friends and they also suffered.

That was one of the ones that got me too. Immediate skin burning and needing to wash it off.

 

[SeanC]

+2, unfortunately, the same for me as well.

Add me to the list too. Everything I've tried gave me a skin reaction

 

[Cheekee]

A&E oudiction. My face was on fire. Peter said to keep the lid off for a couple of days and it did improve the next shave, but wont buy it again.

 

[adrian ivanovici]

Stirling-Sandalwood: smells like mud

 

[hotmetal]

I probably won't get Extro Cosmesi Arancia Italiana again, sadly, as I absolutely love it but it does tingle my skin a bit afterwards which is slightly odd. It's not quite enough to make me not get it again but for the fact there are so many soaps out there to try, I almost think why buy anything twice! It's the most wonderful orange scent and I do miss it. Maybe there are other orange bombs to try?

 

[Smiffy]

I see many people with an issue on A and E, does anyone know what the problem ingredient might be to cause a reaction in so many?

 

[Estariol]

I probably won't get Extro Cosmesi Arancia Italiana again, sadly, as I absolutely love it but it does tingle my skin a bit afterwards which is slightly odd. It's not quite enough to make me not get it again but for the fact there are so many soaps out there to try, I almost think why buy anything twice! It's the most wonderful orange scent and I do miss it. Maybe there are other orange bombs to try?

How about buying only the splash with that scent?

 

[Optometrist]

I see many people with an issue on A and E, does anyone know what the problem ingredient might be to cause a reaction in so many?

I've had a reaction to some A&E soaps and splashes and it's typically due to the scenting oils. Fragrance oil reactions tend to be more frequent than those from essential oils. A&E soaps are known for their higher than average scent strengths and will be an additional factor.

 

[p.b]

How about buying only the splash with that scent?

For me the ASL are often worse than the soaps for causing irritation

 

[ischiapp]

Erasmic Shave Stick.
I'm trying to kill it, but it's hard ...

 

[art101980]

TOBS Sandalwood
The scent is awful and it irritates my skin very badly

 

[chazt]

Lately, most eucalyptus scented products simply don’t please my nose. Blasphemy to some, but frankly Proraso Green AS just doesn’t agree with me. I’ve bought and tried it twice, as I really enjoy menthol, and really wanted to like the product. However, the second time was definitely my final foray with the P-Green splash (fwiw, I don’t have an issue with the scent of the P-Green shave cream which is unlike the splash).

 

[Gairdner]

TOBS Sandalwood
The scent is awful and it irritates my skin very badly

It doesn’t irritate my skin but it certainly irritates my nose. Smells buggerall like Sandalwood. Nasty stuff.

Denim Original aftershave. To quote @Dr Watson, “Made me gag.” Truly awful beyond words.

Ralon Afteshave. Supposed to be the original form of Swiss Pitralon (which is great). I feel bad because a friend sent me it but by ‘eck, it’s minging. Not as a bad as Denim though I still needed to wash it off immediately.

Pashana aftershave. Bought some way back when. Gagged and threw it in the bin. Then the neighbours complained about how bad my bin smelled - true story! Possibly the worst.