I never tried the original, my journey into traditional shaving coincided with the Blue's discontinuation. However, this stuff is really nice...
Scent: Smells clean and fresh, like linen in a cool sea breeze.
Sillage: None, its a skin scent after 30 seconds.
Longevity: Thirty minutes to an hour, after that I couldn't smell it.
Face feel: Its alcoholic with some oil, it doesnt leave the skin sticky per se but mine was slightly tacky. Menthol burn is on par with Floid Vigoroso (in my opinion.) It felt refreshing and soothing upon application... One of the best AS I've used in that respect, cant comment on healing properties as I didn't need it but certainly not bad
Eight hours later: My face still feels smooth and supple, much more so than usual.
I would say its an absolute bargain for the price and will be stocking up on a couple more bottles once they've fixed the top cap issue.