Blade Sharpeners and then some...

R181

Grumpy old man
I guess that is possible but all those sharpening methods came from a time when people had a mindset that you sharpened blades when they became dull. Then there was the great depression/dirty 30s thrown in too.

Bob
 
DE blades are cheap and - as they are composed of a single sheet of metal - they're easier to recycle than more complex and expensive cartridge blades or disposable razors.

But since avoiding unecessary wastes was also a factor in my switch to DE shaving, I have ordered a used Siemens DE blades sharpener on eBay, and I've tested it on my dull Merkur Super blade :


I assumed the sharpener would be either ineffective on modern stainless steel blades and the blade would not regain sharpness, or I would loose the coating and the edge would rust, or it would change the soft/aggressive profile of the blade...

It turns out it's an effective device : that dull blade is now as good as new and as soft as it was. No rust so far. When I shaved with it, I had the feeling this blade was brand new.

I still need to test if the blade can still get 5 to 6 shaves though. And I don't know how many times you get to sharpen a blade before the edge is not exposed enough anymore.

Unless some zombie invasion occurs and I can't get new blades anymore, I have no real-life use-case for such a device : to me, it's only a nice-to-have curiosity. Maybe it can be useful in the case of specific hard to find blades ?

In post-WW2 Europe context, this kind of device makes perfect sense : every raw material was scarce and in high demand, especially steel. DE blades would be more expensive than they are now, made of carbon steel prone to rust, and often not available in stores.
 
FYI : I got 3 good 3-passes shaves out of that resharpened Merkur Super blade. On starting the 4th it was tugging notably more than a normal blade, so I sharpened it again : "as good as new" again.

I don't know how long it would take for it to actually become useless, and I don't want to stay stuck now on that particular blade forever.

If I get 3 shaves out of it again, I'll keep it as a spare and use it from time to time, just to check of many sharpening operations it might take...

I still have... I don't know... hundreds (?) of other blade models to test.
 

slapo

It's... alive!
@Mangegrain How much cleaning/maintenance did you have to do on the sharpener itself after you bought it?
Most I've seen on eBay looked like they were about to fall apart, or were pretty grimey.
 
@Mangegrain How much cleaning/maintenance did you have to do on the sharpener itself after you bought it?
Most I've seen on eBay looked like they were about to fall apart, or were pretty grimey.
Nothing. That sharpener was in good shape and clean.

Now, really, I do it more for fun. I bought 10 Wilkinson blades today for 3.44 €. So there really is no point in resharpening a blade that will normally last me a week. The potential savings are no more than a few € per year. I paid 15 € for this sharpener : the ROI is maybe 5 to 10 years.
 
FYI : I got 3 good shaves again out of Merkur Super blade that was resharpened twice.
So out of this blade I got 6 good shaves when it was new, 3 shaves after the first sharpening operation, 3 shaves again after the second sharpening : that's 12 shaves ! 3-passes each.

It looks like a sharpener could extend a blade lifetime "forever".

I'll keep this blade as a spare, use it from time to time, count the number of shaves and sharpenings, and check if/when that blade finally wears out.
 
Top