Blackmass
Forum GOD!
TBH I don't think the soaps have been bad, it's more than likely user error.I've been quite fortunate, the worst two I've used are Wilkinson Sword Blue Bowl and Craptree & Evilling.
The soaps I don't like are some of the most popular and highly regarded by everyone else but me.
I don't like the ones I've tried from Stirling, OSP and Phoenix and Beau. I know I know.
I don't like the soap base on them. I find them too oily and greasy.