Hi Chris, hard to pick just one for me..there are a lot out there. But personally, it has to be something either citrus or mentholated, or both.
A few recommendations would be:
Artisan:
Wickham 1912 Apricus (basically a citrus aromatic, smells a lot like AdP Colonia)
Wickham 1912 Cashmere (smells like a fresh laundry type scent clean and good for spring or summer)
Wickham 1912 Club Cola ( It's smells effervescent like a fizzy lemonade or cola..amazing scent)
P&B Denali (Peppermint, camphor, menthol)
CRSW Limenthol (Lime, ginger, menthol)
Stirling Lemon Chill (Lemon and Menthol)
Stirling MITA
B&M Reserve cool (basically Floid blue scent a classy barbershop, citrus, powder and clean scent)
OSP Grapefruit and menthol
Fitjar Folgefonn ( Spruce, eucalyptus, menthol.. really good!)
Non Artisan:
Proraso Green ( Cheap, classic soap with Eucalyptus and Menthol . Seems passé nowadays, for some reason)
Kent Luxury (OK it's a cream but smells great and lot's of menthol)
Czech & Speake Oxford and Cambridge (Lovely herbal Lavender and a favourite)
D R Harris Arlington (Citrus and Fern but smells like an old style European cologne..think 4711)
Meissner Tremonia Dark Limes (with the splash an amazing, fresh, invigorating experience and very natural lime scent)
Hope this helps there's loads more..